If you like your whiskies smokey, really smokey, then this is it. Every sniff reminds me of my smokey clothes after a night at the campfire. Forget your subtles hints of this and that, this is a strong, punchy whisky, with a substantial finish. Altogether a very satisfying malt.
- Martin Smith, Scotland, 16th Feb '13
Agree with Gordon - there is a lovely charcoal thing going on. It lives up to the "bonfire on the beach" description, with more smoke than std Caol Ila 12 BUT unless Im mistaken there's a slightly acrid aftertaste which points to the addition of E150(caramel). The colour, no-age statement & absence of any label info all shout “this dram's been played with”. A good winter malt, but get a few non-chill filtered/uncoloured on your shelf before buying.
- Sean Sankey, 4th Dec '12
Oh my god! This is possibly the best value for money bottle of whisky I've had this year (and I've had more than I care to admit). Compares very favourably to Lagavulin for example. Has a really unusual hint of coal running through it rather than obvious peat. Truly brilliant.
- Gordon Reeves, 25th Sep '12
This is one bad ass whisky so tasty, really peaty with a lovely spice finnish. Not seen or tasted anoth Caol Ila like it....defo get some.
- Kwaai, 8th Sep '12
Your Review:Rating (1 to 5): Your Name (optional):