36 Customer Reviews

• 5
  don j 2 days ago

  very smooth whiskey like it better thane jack are Jim beam

• 5
  J Spencer 2 days ago

  Very nice. Full flavored but not overpowering.

• 4
  Brad 16 August

  I'm not a fan of bourbon. The corn liquor is just too sweet. My preference is strong, peaty scotch and rye. I've had some high end ryes that failed to live up to expectations. Tincup, for the price, is a very good rye ! I know it has zero snob appeal, and maybe that adds to the appeal for me ! But it will be a staple in my liquor cabinet.

• 5
  Anonymous 31 July

  Smooth and good for the price.

• 4
  Dan 28 July

  Love Tin Cup. I did put in freezer to keep cold. The alcohol % must not be as high, as it did freeze.

• 4
  Kyle 7 June

  Not the most complex whisky on the market but for the price it is quite good. The tincup on top is a nice extra thrown in. Doesn't feel like 84 proof, very smooth and easy drinking. Recommend to new whisky drinkers. Still enjoyable to those who have a more experienced palate

• 5
  Whiskey Biscuits 31 May

  Found a new favorite. Love Tincup.

• 5
  Doc 23 May

  Initially a little "hot" up front but a great finish. Was tasting others when I tried this. 2 days later tried again by itself and was pleasantly surprised...Have a new "keeper". Pour a taster, neat, and add about a tablespoon ice water...opens the flavor greatly...

• 5
  Whiskey Bent 30 April

  Had my first drink in Colorado last Elk season. Finally found it in Ohio. Will be keeping this in my cabinet from now on

• 5
  Tin Cup=Good 23 April

  Tin Cup is an American whiskey that rivals the smoothest whiskeys I've had. The profile is warm and not overbearing on the tounge and leaves a smooth finish, leaving a subtle and flavorful note on the palet. I wrote this review sampling Tin Cup in the included tin cup.

• 4
  Anonymous 14 April

  Just sippin one on my birthday for the first time and it tastes damn good to me.

• 4
  Jimmy Mac 7 April

  Pretty smooth drink. I am seeing a good trend with the Colorado bourbons, first Breckenridge and now Tin Cup...very nice

• 5
  Dennis Facciolo 27 March

  Truly wonderful!

• 5
  Mark Z. 10 March

  Wife bought it for me as a birthday present, knowing I love rye and bourbon...this did not disappoint. Great "whiskey", great price point, two fingers on two rocks....

• 2
  CF Gauss 6 February

  Middle of the road, but decent for the price. Worth trying for the value. Most reviews have the tasting notes spot on. Great bottle, but probably won't consider it a part of a "must have" collection.

• 2
  Danimal 9 January

  Very cool bottle hiding some very mediocre not-really-bourbon whiskey. Sweet up front but no depth of flavor. Reminds me more of a blended canadian than a bourbon or rye. I will finish the bottle (and amybe keep it for decoration) but will not buy it again.

• 4
  Rupe 19 December 2015

  Great flavor. .spice is highlighted on my palate. ..

• 5
  MoreTears 8 November 2015

  Regarding the claim of "Anonymous" that this is a high-rye bourbon from MGP -- not quite, and it isn''t bourbon at all. Tincup sourced two different bourbons from MGP (each one with a slightly different mashbill) and blended them together, but they also added some Stranahan''s Colorado Whiskey, which is distilled from 100% malted barley. With that malt-whiskey additive, this product cannot be legally labeled "bourbon," which is why the generic term "American Whiskey" is used in the name instead of "Bourbon."

• 4
  Whisky dawg 24 October 2015

  This is my go to whisky very smooth and easy to drink

• 5
  Rob, Edinburgh 16 September 2015

  Came across Tincup in Edinburgh recently, and had to have it! Not at all disappointed......a great whiskey! Great all round flavour.