34 Customer Reviews

• 5
  Anonymous 2 days ago

  Nice. Rich, smooth, warm flavor. Really enjoyable. Different.

• 5
  Anonymous 16 March

  Smooth with more flavour than standard Jamie's. only had a couple of nips on a promotional night but would severely recommend this drink.

• 5
  Carol 11 March

  This is delicious whiskey, deep and rich. Very impressed.

• 5
  Sean P Nelson 3 March

  Wow! I'm truly surprised! This is smooth with notes of caramel... Very buttery. Maybe a touch of sweet coffee on the end. Smells great as you're sipping. I'm drinking this on the rocks and it's great. Honestly, I like this much better than regular Jameson.

• 5
  Mary Meyers 26 February

  I tried the caskmates stout edition at a whiskey tasting event last week. It is an amazing taste delight. The IPA edition is excellent as well, by I prefer the Stout edition.

• 5
  Tom McCallan 6 January

  Great easy drinking whiskey. Definitely worth trying.

• 5
  Darek Duy Khanh 4 January

  First of all, I don't expected that whiskey is that good... I thought it is another whiskey like Jameson Crested good but not enough but I was wrong. This is one of my favorite Jameson's smothness, complexity, buttery tastes very enjoyable. This product surprised me more than Jameson Select Reserve ( not Black Barrel didn't tried yet). Good Job Jameson

• 4
  Stuart Stanley 26 December 2017

  Great whiskey with a well rounded flavor! You can smell the stout barrels faintly on the nose. Hints of coffee and caramel are balanced with a slight hoppiness. For the price, one of the best drinking Irish whiskeys on the market. My daughters were upset when they both gave me a bottle for Christmas until they realized that I was ecstatic about it!

• 5
  Rob V 4 December 2017

  Jameson or Tullemore Dew used to be my go to's until I found Caskmates. It's a happy marriage of mild coffee, hops and caramel notes with solid whisky notes. The mild oakiness sets off the spice and vanilla undertones. I always have a bottle of this in the house. It's great to sip on the rocks or shoot as an accent to your favorite stout or Irish ale.

• 4
  Freiherr 18 November 2017

  Very pleasant taste. Instantly reminded me of bourbon. It smells great and has a real smooth Jameson taste! I recommend

• 4
  Hedge774 5 November 2017

  I had read and re read all the reviews of Caskmates before I went shopping. From the reviews, I surmised that this had to the whiskey that was a perfect fit for me. I love Jameson's original blend and Black Barrel is my hands down favorite Irish so CM was going to the best of the three. Nope. Not in my opinion anyway. The nose is awesome with chocolate and caramel and the mouth feel is simply amazing. So...why did I feel a bit of a let down? The taste reminded me instantly of a blended scotch. Is it bad? Not by a long shot. In fact I can see why it remains a fan favorite. This whiskey has a distinct personality. My problem was personal preconceived expectations. It isn't Black Barrel, and it wasn't meant to be. I'll not be giving up on this bottle though and I look forward to reading more of your reviews!

• 5
  Anonymous 4 November 2017

  Most enjoyable Jameson in my view

• 5
  Anonymous 20 October 2017

  Smoothest whiskey on the market.

• 5
  Frank Sheppard 17 September 2017

  Great, smooth and mellow,so enjoyable its easy to have another,and then one more.

• 4
  Henry Scroggins Jr 14 September 2017

  It is better than expected

• 5
  Peter G. Davies 10 August 2017

  A versatile whiskey if ever there was one! I tried it in a fantastic Lisbon beer bar where each ale was a treat. Their deal was you could buy a full shot of Jameson Caskmates Stout edition for just 1€ with each beer bought. It was perfect side to every beer I tried (and I did my best!) Each beer seemed to bring a new note to the Jameson. It also does a fine job as a standalone whiskey. Certainly now a firm favorite of mine.

• 5
  Robert Rutkowski 21 June 2017

  Really surprising. Sampled a little this morning and bought a bottle right away. The concept of this whiskey completely intrigued me. I wasn't at all disappointed. The chocolate, cocoa, buttery, stout and caramel flavors were astounding. Its smoothness amazing. Well done Jameson.

• 5
  Anonymous 18 June 2017

  As good as bushmills but smoother

• 5
  [email protected] 15 June 2017

  Converted from JD I've been loyal to since 1963. Smooth and satisfiying. Great ! Price hurts a bit.

• 5
  Joe Giusti 31 May 2017

  best whiskey under $30 out there. I would gladley pay way more for it.